Indian Idol. Farha & Nigam & TRASH……

What is this crap about bhagya and talent?

Public are well informed and they made a decision to oust a candidate and format for the show says so. And kicking of some one that was the judge’s favuorite doesn’t give them that it all happened because of the luck factor. Public opinion is not luck it’s an well informed decision when the sample size is so big (apart from regional bias. The Mumbai man loosing was more eye-opening because traditionally they have supported their own men and been the largest contributor. But this time all India was united and so Mumbaikar’s should understand that there is more of India apart from the mumbai, which is the entertainment hub. Anu malik had accepted the verdict later on the so called respected judge (read Sonu Nigam) thinks that he isn’t ready to digest the public verdict. And he on his own behalf says that all the judges are not ready? What the hell is going on? When you can’t accept the verdict why include that in the format.

Farha and sonu nigam were never fit for judgment. They are just so brazen. I have watched this for the first time and have seen the brazen manner in which they are saying things about the contestants. Judges ko decent hone ko mangta hai yaar. Not every tom dick and Harry can become a judge. One needs to be well versed (not opinionated) in his field to be able to get that coveted chair. Just that you are well known in industry doesn’t mean that you are fit for passing judgment (in your own word’s (Industry is full of kawa’s who are having moti’s).It’s connection luck talent, in that order. that counts now a days.

Look at the way when a batsman gives little bit of dissent they are fined. And here judges are walking out of the podium. They must also be reprimanded. They are not the crowd who can do anything. It’s a bad precedent. Maybe that is for the TRP’s but then it’s how far can one go for this kind of cheap publicity. Never ever they showed a sympathy with the one whom they were repeatedly kicking out of the show. And now behaving like some spoilt child. It must stop here. Bringing Shahrukh Khan as a judge(even if he is the KING) would also amount as tantamount to injustice. The reason being that being successful doesn’t bring that eye’s of a connoisseur (though I have complete faith in him after watching coffee with Karan). Bringing analogy with cricket match the coach or the umpires or the captains aren’t the best player. They are the one who have the understanding of the finer points of their trade. Being successful doesn’t give you that.

Last time Abhijeet Sawant won because of the Mumbai crowd sms support and Sana lost out. Then where are yours judgment. If majority public thinks that one particular person is better, then that’s the end of the story. After all it’s them who have to listen and they make common man star.

Meanwhile amay’s response was quite mature and hat’s of to him.It all made me remember the Sunil Pal’s satire on them at GILC.See the judges Shekhar Suman & Sidhu. They are so dignified even when there is an adult joke is going on. They are the perfect example. Many contestants mould themselves after the feedback. It’s high time that the judges heed to this one.